I have until Jan 15 to decide to return the Galaxy Nexus. I'm going to use that time to further evaluate ICS. I re-flashed 4.0.2 and that seems to have fixed the reception issues and it seems like 4g to 3g hand offs are working properly. That's a big plus. Radio performance is now on par with what I got Pre or either of the Fascinates we have.

The rest of the bugs were minor and definitely software related, so they wouldn't be deal breakers anyway. So that just leaves me with the fact that I don't like ICS as much as I do webOS but prefer the hardware options that Android offers. If the the GN continues to get good data connections, I'll probably keep it and keep tabs webOS, WP and iOS developments.