I am having a difficult time seeing the difference between these two cases.

Is one thinner than the other, that is adds less bulk to the Treo 650?

Is there a difference in weight?

Is the finishing of one better than the other?

Is the belt clip more reliable on one or the other?

Is the fit better?

Finally, am I nuts to think that my screen will be safe if it is facing outward? I can put on a screen protector, and I do have an insurance replacement policy from Verizon, but maybe this is crazy.

Thanks for any help differentiating the two cases and any advise regarding safety of one over the other.

I did purchase the Seidio sled and that works pretty well, but the Treo body is exposed (although itís the back instead of the screen).

Thanks again. Bruce