Educated Customers Ask the Toughest Questions !
Wow, you guys are tough. Ever call a company and feel like you know more than their tech support ? That's what it's like here. My information comes from groups of people that are supposed to know things but often don't or are not up to date. Things are changing quickly. On the other hand, with 2000 posts on this board, you have quite an information source going.
Yesterday was a tough day for 3rd level support but things went well. At least my Treo still works and I hope you guys are doing OK also. Let me say that it's impossible to answer the number of questions on this board, but since ther are lots of duplications at least there are some popular themes. Unfortunately some of the answers may trigger a cyber shotgun blast.
For example "Is the final verdict in on speed yet." Well.... of course not, and it never will be because usage data is being collected and the network will be resized and rerouted as indicated. I'm going to try to put a little more research into the more common questions and avoid shooting from the hip.
Network Speed - An Alternate View
I had the chance Friday to compare the Treo 300 to the T-Mobile Sidekick. The comparison was done over the phone with a T-Mobile beta tester so from some standpoints there is an argument that their network is not loaded down yet but we know it already gets plenty of use.
Here's what I observed. Time to load google. Very primative test indeed. My page was fully loaded while his was still connecting. Now his was supposed to be an always on device so I'm not sure what their connection was, but the general observation and point is that the Treo 300 on Sprint Vision service appears to be faster. Yes they were cached pages. That points to good caching on the Treo. A search for the word Sprint yielded results in about half the time on the Treo. 144kbs ? No way.
This thread is similar to saying is DSL or a Cable Modem the same speed everywhere. Of course not. Do either ever reach their theoretical limit ? DSL comes closer because much less of it is shared. PCS Vision is much closer in theory to Cable Modem service because the radio portion is shared. Since 0's and 1's don't flow through the air yet an analog carrier is still used so if the signal is weak there are retrys or multiple attempts to access the same data.
The easiest comparison I can make is to the current 802.11B equipment. Look at any wireless connection through, say, a Linksys Wireless Access Point. The further you get from the access point, the lower the speed goes. Shotgun blast.