Ok Guys. I've narrowed it down to two cases, can you help me decide?

This one http://blog.treonauts.com/2007/07/treo-case-spe-l.html

or this one http://blog.treonauts.com/2007/05/tr...e_ultra_1.html


I think that I would lean toward the 2nd one, but there were some reviews that it started to fall apart after a few months of use. I guess I could email Andrew and see if there is a warranty on it...

Thanks a lot!