Results 1 to 5 of 5
  1. Stihl's Avatar
    Posts
    741 Posts
    Global Posts
    747 Global Posts
       #1  
    I ask this because I just tried the iphone agent spoof patch and, while I was impressed with the few sites it worked on, I was also disgusted by a few that seemed to have bought entirely into the Apple mantra.

    Every site you go to on your phone has a desktop version, and many, especially within the last several years, have added a mobile version.

    With the coming of the iphone, something changed: many websites began offering iphone specific interfaces which made effective use of the phone's abilities while limiting the amount of clutter users would normally see on a desktop version of the site.

    For a while, this remained unchallenged, party because few phones could realistically compete. HTC would unfurl a high-spec'd phone running WinMo that could get the job done but remained inelegant. More telling was that all the phone manufacturers would release several different phones, all high spec'd and equally mismatched against the iphone; the iphone's specs became upgraded, and as it's screen resolution and size remained constant, it's markset share only increased. The diversity of all of these challengers relegated them to either dealing with desktop versions of websites or using incredibly spartan mobile sites that offered none of the flair of their just-for-iphone stylized cousins.

    Things have been changing though.

    Palm and google have made great strides in the mobile browsing arena, and also-ran phones like the new chocolate and instinct offer more fully fledged browsing experiences due to the larger, iphone like screen. While there is still much diversity, the ability gap is closing in terms of display potential and interface.

    Until relatively recently, it was common to see a website have a blahblahblah.com/iphone as well as a blahblahblah.com/mobile address. Facebook seemed to be ahead of the game in realizing that mobile versions of sites are great for dumbphones, but touch interface phones need an iphone style treatment. Currently, every smartphone goes to touch.facebook.com by default (of course, facebook is so large a company that it's almost not a good example-it's ahead of the game because it both has to be and can afford to be).

    My question is when will websites at large stop treating noniphone pda users as second class citizens? How long will it take, and what can palm or other manufacturers do about it? Will it take google's muscle to even the playing field? Will flash be the great equalizer that makes non-iphone pda users suddenly the market to refresh webpage design for?

    Or will the situation never truly change? As Apple's marketshare continues to climb, will web browsing innovation be the only cure to the lack of ease through efficiency to which the iphone is privy and we are not?
  2. Adjei's Avatar
    Posts
    277 Posts
    Global Posts
    708 Global Posts
    #2  
    When the other browsers and platforms stop being second class.
  3. cashen's Avatar
    Posts
    759 Posts
    Global Posts
    773 Global Posts
    #3  
    Quote Originally Posted by Adjei View Post
    When the other browsers and platforms stop being second class.
    Zing!
  4. #4  
    Well,

    If you are spoofing your user agent to look like you, too, are an iphone, then you are part of the problem.

    The best thing to do is to write the folks who maintain the site. If they get revenue from you and don't change, then stop giving them your money or your eyeballs for advertising.

    Not sure what else we can do. Unfortunately, we are a minority of users for these sites. Even more so if you are spoofing your user agent.
  5. s219's Avatar
    Posts
    498 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,008 Global Posts
    #5  
    Quote Originally Posted by Adjei View Post
    When the other browsers and platforms stop being second class.
    That about sums it up.

    For a web project I worked on about 6 months ago, the client only wanted an iPhone version, as iPhones made up over 95% of mobile traffic to their site. Many companies see the same sort of usage and get hypnotized by the iPhone aura. Until other platforms generate enough traffic to warrant attention, I think they will be treated like second class citizens. This type of marginalization happens all the time in technology. iPhone just happened to be the first phone with a decent browser, and it went on to dominate fairly quickly.

Posting Permissions