I'd really like to use a cradle, and prefer to use a form-fitting case to keep from being bulky. Assuming I dock my phone once a day, a couple of questions occured to me for some more experienced users...

For the Vaja I-Volution & Krussell Classic
1) Is the case tight and annoying to get on and off, especially if you do it often?
2) On the other hand will taking the case on/off making the case loose and less secure?

Side question:
My third choice is Krusell Handit Multidapt since it looks like that flip lid detaches in the product pictures for it. Does it actually detach?

Thanks!