06/15/2011, 01:04 PM
I actually started, but it didn't seem to make much sense to continue because after I had gotten most of the way through, I didn't see any way we were going to come to any type of agreement. It was just a waste of my time, and maybe yours, too.
Originally Posted by Suntan
To me, it seemed like a lot of your arguments preclude there being any B's that could be awarded in several categories (GPU, Resolution, and Ports, for example).
It also seemed like you drew some fairly odd lines in the sand which would then be used as your rationale behind lowering the grade (the phone would have gotten a "B" for screen if the screen had been part of a slab phone or lacked a gesture area needed to meet your proportional size requirements).
Quite frankly, you didn't grade the phone so much as you established the grade you were going to give the phone and then backed into logic that would support the grade you wanted to give.