Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 22
  1.    #1  
    Yes, bought a Sprint Treo 600 off Ebay that I just found out it was stolen. Paypal won't refund me back my money. Can I take this guy to small claims court in my state if he's from another state? Need some options here.
    You never lived until you almost died!
  2. #2  
    First, contact the seller and demand your money back.

    If that doesn't work, call the police where the seller lives. They'll surely be interested in someone selling stolen property.

    Next, try PayPal again, this time with a police report. If they're of no help, contact the Attorney General (state or federal, either will work) and inform them that PayPal is facilitating the sale of stolen property.

    You should be able to get your money back without the hassle and expense of small claims, where receiving money from the judgement is never an easy task.
  3. #3  
    Quote Originally Posted by IceMike
    Yes, bought a Sprint Treo 600 off Ebay that I just found out it was stolen. Paypal won't refund me back my money. Can I take this guy to small claims court in my state if he's from another state? Need some options here.
    Curious - how did you find out it was stolen.

    Pamela-->still checking serial numbers online for her stoken Coolpix 990.
    Using my treo 650 for business:
    DesignExtend.com
  4. BrettS's Avatar
    Posts
    211 Posts
    Global Posts
    214 Global Posts
    #4  
    I believe you may be able to sue him, but you need to do it in his locality. I'm a bit surprised that paypal won't do anything. What did they say?

    Brett
  5. #5  
    I would think eBay also would get involved (same company even). Seeing that they assisted in facilitating the sale - which is clearly against their TOS.

    Pamela
    Using my treo 650 for business:
    DesignExtend.com
  6. #6  
    Is it a sprint treo? If it was, did you check to make sure the ESN was clear (and it wasnt stolen)?

    I am not sure how you could verify this with a GSM phone (cing, att, etc.)
    Palm III-->Palm IIIxe-->Palm 505-->Samsung i300-->Treo 600-->PPC 6600-->Treo 650-->Treo 700wx-->BB Pearl--> BB Curve

  7. #7  
    You can usually sue him in your own state. Most states have "long arm" jurisdiction statutes which allow you to obtain subject matter jurisdiction. However, to obtain personal jurisdiction (both personal and subject matter jurisdiction are necessary), you will have to serve him in your state. Federal court is out since you do not have over $75,000 in damages (min. for diversity jurisdiction).

    Suing him in his home state will cost too much (plus, even if you have a judgment, actually getting the money from an individual is very costly unless he owns real property).
  8. #8  
    I'd be surprised if eBay wouldn't help you out in some way, and PayPal should be able to impound funds in his account.

    EBay is now the place of choice for disposing of stolen property...
  9. #9  
    Quote Originally Posted by jctonett
    I'd be surprised if eBay wouldn't help you out in some way, and PayPal should be able to impound funds in his account.

    EBay is now the place of choice for disposing of stolen property...
    This is quite true...people do seem to have a certain level of anonymity (even if its just perceived).

    Going through paypal will only help if the money is still in the other guys account. Typically these thieves will move the money as soon as its transferred.
    Palm III-->Palm IIIxe-->Palm 505-->Samsung i300-->Treo 600-->PPC 6600-->Treo 650-->Treo 700wx-->BB Pearl--> BB Curve

  10.    #10  
    I purchased the Treo off Ebay after noticing that the advertisement said GSM phone. Once the phone arrived in the mail, I noticed it was a Sprint model. So, I tried to contact the seller for a full refund but was unsuccessful. So I contacted Paypal and Ebay and they did their usual BS investigation. They came to the conclusion that the guy was in the wrong and tried to issued me a refund. Paypal sent me an email saying they were unsuccessful in collecting funds from the guy. So I tried to cut my losses by selling the phone. After selling the phone, the person who bought it called me and told me that sprint say the phone was stolen. So now I need to take the easiest route to get my money back. I can care less if the guy get in trouble... I just want my money back!
    You never lived until you almost died!
  11. #11  
    Quote Originally Posted by IceMike
    After selling the phone, the person who bought it called me and told me that sprint say the phone was stolen. So now I need to take the easiest route to get my money back. I can care less if the guy get in trouble... I just want my money back!
    Have you called Sprint (or gone into a local store) and told them what has happened? I had this happen to a friend...bought a phone on ebay, it had a lien on it because the guy didnt pay the bill, they let him pay a portion of that to bring the account current and then allowed him to reassign the ESN to his account.

    Good Luck
    Palm III-->Palm IIIxe-->Palm 505-->Samsung i300-->Treo 600-->PPC 6600-->Treo 650-->Treo 700wx-->BB Pearl--> BB Curve

  12.    #12  
    I never checked out the ESN before purchasing because I thought I was buying a GSM model. Why can't there be capital punishment for thieves? I want to take my freshly oiled kabar and slide it across this guys neck!
    You never lived until you almost died!
  13. #13  
    IceMike, you're not going to like hearing this but it sounds to me like you would be in as much trouble as the guy who sold it to you. Selling stolen propery is selling stolen property. He might not have known it was stolen either (at least that would be his story).

    Did you refund the guy who purchased it from you, and hopefully get the phone back? If you got it back, make a police report that you bought it and turn it in. Take your losses, as it's better than being caught with a hot phone that you've sold once.
  14.    #14  
    Well, the only way you can tell if the phone is stolen is by going to a Sprint store. My intentions were not to buy a CDMA phone, but a GSM Treo since my account is with TMobile. If I knew the phone was a CDMA model, I wouldn't have bought it. And I wouldn't have sold it if I knew it was stolen. I already issued the guy that bought the phone a refund. And he contacted his credit card company for extra measures. Paypal should be held liable since they promise refunds for situations like this. I can't wait til Google get their merchant system up and running and put Paypal out of business.
    Quote Originally Posted by RickMG
    IceMike, you're not going to like hearing this but it sounds to me like you would be in as much trouble as the guy who sold it to you. Selling stolen propery is selling stolen property. He might not have known it was stolen either (at least that would be his story).

    Did you refund the guy who purchased it from you, and hopefully get the phone back? If you got it back, make a police report that you bought it and turn it in. Take your losses, as it's better than being caught with a hot phone that you've sold once.
    You never lived until you almost died!
  15. #15  
    Quote Originally Posted by IceMike
    Paypal should be held liable since they promise refunds for situations like this.
    That goes without saying. You should've been able to get your money back, as I always believed that they guaranteed that anything purchased using ebay was, in fact, the item that was advertised. " PayPal Buyer Protection
    Free Coverage now up to $1,000"

    http://pages.ebay.com/paypal/buyer/protection.html

    The problem becomes this, as soon as you found out it was stolen, it's your responsibilty to turn it in. Then you should go after PayPal. Those are your only legal options. I'm only trying to advise you as to the correct action to take now. I can't imagine how PayPal could turn down your claim with a police report in hand or a statement from Sprint verifying that the object sold to you on ebay was stolen. I'd be taking PayPal and ebay to small claims court if they turned it down. You won't have to worry about collecting from them.
  16.    #16  
    Anybody that has got taken on Ebay or/and Paypal, knows that their business operations are all smoke and mirrors. Paypal offer refunds up to 1000 but don't deliver when someone gets scammed or defrauded. Their acts of discipline consist of suspending the user and freezing funds in an empty account. So, I am going to take Paypal to court for not living up to their refund promise. Somebody has to be held accountable for their actions.
    You never lived until you almost died!
  17. hsk
    hsk is offline
    hsk's Avatar
    Posts
    262 Posts
    Global Posts
    284 Global Posts
    #17  
    Hmm.. I've never had a bad experience buying on Ebay but I've only may be bought 10 things there, and never sold anything. I can't imagine how you would deal with buying something and having what's shipped totally different (like CDMA instead of GSM), I'd be pissed!! Did the seller have a lot of + feedback or had they done something like that before? Did you at least warn others?

    I've never bought anything expensive unless they have at least 100 or so positive seller feedback and negligible negatives.
  18. #18  
    Quote Originally Posted by IceMike
    So, I am going to take Paypal to court for not living up to their refund promise. Somebody has to be held accountable for their actions.

    The other good thing about taking them to court. If a previous poster is correct and you can go to your local small claims court, PayPal will have to have a representative there or else you will get a default judgement. You have got to figure that it wouldn't be worth their while to pay someone to be there for the amount of a Treo. And I'm sure that if they get a judgement against them, that they pay it. If they show, you have to think that they're going to lose. In fact, it might be ebay I'd take to court for selling stolen items on their site. Who knows?
  19. #19  
    Good luck, paypal and ebay should absolutely be held liable
    1 | 2
  20. #20  
    IceMike, sorry to hear of your troubles. Sounds like you've got a mess and a complicated one. Find out when the phone was reported stolen. Was it before you bought it or after you sold it (or in between)?

    A while ago, I sold a brand new never activated 650 on ebay that I have receipts for. The mistake I made was making the ESN number available to bidders who asked for it. After I sent the phone to the buyer after auction close, the buyer said the phone is a stolen phone. Talking to Sprint revealed the phone was activated and reported stolen on the same day while in transit to the buyer. Sprint would not tell me who activated and reported the phone stolen and didn't care that I had the original receipts and would not release the phone from stolen status. Meanwhile the buyer wanted a refund. I wasn't about to issue a refund without getting the phone back first. Ultimately, Sprint wanted the person with the phone to go into a Sprint store before they would change the stolen status after I showed them proof of original purchase and Ebay sale. The buyer did finally go to the Sprint store and got the phone activated. To this day I do not know who pulled this prank or scam. The moral of the story is do not give out the ESN number when you sell your phone, especially if it is worth a substantial amount.

    Good luck taking Ebay or paypal to court. And let us know how you make out. It is too bad but there are so many scammers out there on Ebay and with the high fees makes it a real turn off to buy and sell there.
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions